Text versus Numerical Methods to Describe Periodontal Health Status by John Martin, D. D. S



Download 57 Kb.
Date29.01.2017
Size57 Kb.
Text versus Numerical Methods to Describe Periodontal Health Status
by John Martin, D.D.S.

Periodontal health status can be described using one of the following five diagnoses, listed in order of increasing disease severity:


  • Health

  • Gingivitis

  • Beginning Periodontitis

  • Moderate Periodontitis

  • Severe Periodontitis

These diagnoses assume that a single entity, like a tooth, quadrant or mouth is being described. Generally a periodontal diagnosis describes the condition of the mouth using a quadrant as the basic diagnostic unit. Four quadrants allow the concept of extent of disease to be used along with severity. Disease extent is based on the number of quadrants affected. The terms localized and generalized are used to describe disease extent. For example 1 and 2 quadrants are classified as localized and 3 and 4 quadrants are classified as generalized. Combining 5 stages of disease severity with 2 categories of disease extent gives 9 unique descriptions. (Localized health is not possible.)




  • Health

  • Localized gingivitis

  • Generalized gingivitis

  • Localized beginning periodontitis

  • Generalized beginning periodontitis

  • Localized moderate periodontitis

  • Generalized moderate periodontitis

  • Localized severe periodontitis

  • Generalized severe periodontitis

These 9 text descriptions are too few to adequately describe the diagnosis for a 4-quadrant mouth as there are 625 diagnostic combinations using 5 diagnoses for 4 quadrants. This number is arrived at by multiplying 5, the number of possible diagnoses for each quadrant, by 5 by 5 by 5, (5 x 5 x 5 x 5 = 625). One possible situation is 1 quadrant has gingivitis, 1 has beginning periodontitis, 1 has moderate periodontitis, and 1 has severe periodontitis. While a text description is possible, it is too long to be useful. 625 diagnostic combinations is a worst case example as the calculation assumes that the order of diagnoses is important. To describe this effect assume that the diagnosis for the mouth is determined by the diagnosis for the lower jaw and the upper jaw. The tables below use H to designate health, G for gingivitis, B for beginning periodontitis, M for moderate periodontitis, and S for severe periodontitis.







Upper jaw diagnosis

H

G

B

M

S

Lower


jaw

diagnosis



H

HH

HG

HB

HM

HS

G

GH

GG

GB

GM

GS

B

BM

BG

BB

BM

BS

M

MH

MG

MB

MM

MS

S

SH

SG

SB

SM

SS

This example results in 25 combinations. But it assumes that the order of diagnosis for each jaw is important. By eliminating this restriction the number of combinations is reduced to 15, identified by the grey background.







Upper jaw diagnosis

H

G

B

M

S

Lower


jaw

diagnosis



H

HH

HG

HB

HM

HS

G

GH

GG

GB

GM

GS

B

BH

BG

BB

BM

BS

M

MH

MG

MB

MM

MS

S

SH

SG

SB

SM

SS

These 15 combinations can be correlated with the following text descriptions:


HH Health

HG Localized gingivitis

HB Localized beginning periodontitis

HM Localized moderate periodontitis

HS Localized severe periodontitis

GG Generalized gingivitis

GB Localized gingivitis and localized beginning periodontitis

GM Localized gingivitis and localized moderate periodontitis

GS Localized gingivitis and localized severe periodontitis

BB Generalized beginning periodontitis

BM Localized beginning and localized moderate periodontitis

BS Localized beginning and localized severe periodontitis

MM Generalized moderate periodontitis

MS Localized moderate and severe periodontitis

SS Generalized severe periodontitis
Now assume that the mouth is divided into three segments. This example would require a 3-dimensional cube to diagram as shown above. This is too complex to be done here. Instead this is a partial list of diagnostic combinations.

HHH


HHG

HHB


HHM

HHS


HGH

HBH


HMH

HSH


HGG

HGB


HGM

HGS


HBG and so on until all 5 x 5 x 5 = 125 combinations are listed.

Again, these represent combinations where the order is important. When the order is not important then the combinations is reduced to 35. This can be done by counting the number of segments with the same diagnosis. In this manner HBH = HHB = BHH = 2 healthy and 1 beginning periodontitis, which could be described as localized beginning periodontitis. The same text diagnosis, however, could correspond to the situations BBH = BHB = HBB = 1 healthy and 2 beginning periodontitis. Alternatively if BBH is called generalized beginning periodontitis, then this inadequately distinguishes it from BBB. Similarly there is no short and simple text description for BMS. The task of assigning text diagnoses worsens when four quadrants or six sextants are used to determine a whole mouth diagnosis, where the number of combinations is 70 and 210 respectively.


There is a solution.
It is possible to use the method of counting sextants with a specific diagnosis to generate a number and correlating this number to a score that ranges from 1 for health to 100 for the most severe and extensive disease condition. Internal consistency can be accommodated, meaning that a score of 36 corresponds to every sextant having a diagnosis of generalized moderate periodontitis, regardless of how many sextants have teeth. In other words, the patient who has only lower anterior teeth that have moderate periodontitis will have the same score of 36 as the patient who has only lower teeth with each of the 3 sextants having moderate periodontitis, and the patient who is missing the upper anterior teeth with each of the 5 sextants having moderate periodontitis.
The correlation of the numeric score with the text diagnosis groupings might seem unusual as the range is not uniform.


Score__Diagnosis_Group'>Score

Diagnosis Group

1

Health

2-3

Gingivitis

4-10

Beginning Periodontitis

11-36

Moderate Periodontitis

37-100

Severe Periodontitis

The explanation of why there is a large variance in scores for diagnosis groups can be explained by referring back to the 9-item list of diagnoses for severity and extent and the lower jaw - upper jaw diagnosis example. The number of combinations, listed in the rightmost column includes in its count the most severe stage of disease. Hence GB counts as beginning periodontitis; not as gingivitis. The 15 possible combinations correlate with 9 text descriptions and 5 diagnosis groups in an unequal distribution amongst diagnostic groups.




Text

Combinations

Diagnostic

Group

# of combinations

Health

HH

Health

1

Localized gingivitis

HG

Gingivitis

2

Generalized gingivitis

GG

Localized beginning periodontitis

HB, GB

Beginning periodontitis


3


Generalized beginning periodontitis

BB

Localized moderate periodontitis

HM, GM, BM

Moderate periodontitis


4


Generalized moderate periodontitis

MM

Localized severe periodontitis

HS, GS, BS, MS

Severe periodontitis


5


Generalized severe periodontitis

SS

The unequal distribution of scores for a diagnosis group is a result of an increased number of possible combinations as disease severity increases. When 6 sextants are used the total number of combinations is 210. 126 of these have 1 or more sextants with a diagnosis of severe periodontitis, 56 have 1 or more sextants with a diagnosis of moderate periodontitis, 21 have beginning periodontitis, 6 gingivitis, and 1 health.


Seventeen text diagnoses can be correlated with the 1 to 100 score range.


Score

Diagnosis Group

Text Diagnosis

1

Health

Health


2-3

Gingivitis

Gingivitis


4-10

Beginning Periodontitis

Localized Beginning Periodontitis

Generalized Beginning Periodontitis




11-36

Moderate Periodontitis

Localized Beginning and Moderate Periodontitis

Localized Moderate Periodontitis

Generalized Beginning to Moderate Periodontitis

Generalized Beginning and Localized Moderate Periodontitis

Generalized Moderate Periodontitis


37-100

Severe Periodontitis

Localized Beginning and Severe Periodontitis

Localized Moderate and Severe Periodontitis

Localized Severe Periodontitis

Generalized Beginning to Severe Periodontitis

Generalized Beginning and Localized Severe Periodontitis

Generalized Moderate to Severe Periodontitis

Generalized Moderate and Localized Severe Periodontitis

Generalized Severe Periodontitis



Text descriptions for diagnosis are more complicated, less descriptive, and hence, less useful than an internally consistent numeric score. For example an improvement in health is more likely to be captured in the numeric score.





Share with your friends:


The database is protected by copyright ©dentisty.org 2019
send message

    Main page